Trust factor: How SA athleisure brands win Instagram commerce

These conversations are based on one of the most significant shifts in consumer behaviour: the rise of Instagram as a primary shopping destination. Although promising substantial returns, Instagram commerce poses inherent challenges around trust-building that many SA retailers are not fully equipped to navigate.

Source: DRNGD. (n.d.). Run the city & dominate winter in the DRNGD longsleeve Elite tee [Photograph]. Retrieved July 21, 2025, from https://dranged.co.za/product-category/dranged/

Instagram has evolved into a collective digital marketplace where consumers discover, evaluate, and purchase products through immersive visual experiences. In this environment, people can interact with brands, share experiences, and influence purchasing decisions through authentic peer-to-peer connections.

The advantages of marketing athleisure on Instagram are numerous: the ability to reach targeted demographics with precision, collect valuable behavioural data to refine marketing strategies, and create cost-effective campaigns that require minimal physical infrastructure investment. Through strategic Instagram commerce, businesses can build brand loyalty and drive sales, particularly appealing to Generation Y males who represent a significant opportunity in the SA athleisure market (Euromonitor, 2024; Statista, 2024).

Generation Y males are digitally native and comfortable navigating social commerce platforms, making them a crucial demographic for businesses looking to leverage Instagram's commercial potential. Research confirms that 56.9% of Gen Y males in South Africa actively use Instagram, with the majority concentrated in metropolitan areas like Johannesburg (Goldstruck & Patricios, 2021).

These consumers engage with athleisure brands through immersive and interactive content that allows them to visualise products in real-world contexts. This includes authentic user-generated content, virtual try-on experiences, and community-driven product reviews that help consumers make informed decisions. The shift towards health-conscious lifestyles, accelerated by Covid-19, has made athleisure particularly appealing to this demographic.

Despite the considerable opportunities presented by Instagram commerce, building genuine consumer trust remains the critical challenge. Recent research reveals that South African Generation Y males exhibit sophisticated scepticism about online shopping, particularly given concerns about payment security, product authenticity, and delivery reliability. As cybersecurity expert Louis B. Rosenberg notes about digital platforms, they have become "the most powerful tools of persuasion" ever created, but success depends on transparent risk management rather than risk avoidance (Rosenburg, 2023). This insight challenges conventional marketing wisdom and highlights the unique dynamics of the SA digital marketplace.

The trust challenge is particularly acute because Instagram commerce platforms collect extensive behavioural data beyond traditional click-through metrics. They monitor engagement patterns, social interactions, and purchasing preferences – creating detailed consumer profiles that, while valuable for personalisation, raise legitimate privacy concerns (Wang & Herrando, 2019). SA consumers are increasingly aware of data protection rights, making transparency about data usage essential for maintaining credibility. Additionally, the prevalence of fake reviews and inauthentic social proof has made this demographic particularly discerning about the credibility of online endorsements.

How, then, do South African athleisure retailers successfully navigate the trust-building requirements of Instagram commerce while capitalising on its commercial potential?

Several evidence-based strategies have proven effective for managing trust and risk concerns in Instagram commerce.

Implement transparent security communication:

Rather than minimising risk discussions, successful SA retailers acknowledge potential concerns while demonstrating comprehensive protection measures. Research shows that transparent risk acknowledgment actually increases trust rather than diminishing it. This includes prominently displaying local payment partnerships, explaining fraud protection protocols, and providing clear contact information for customer support.

Leverage authentic local content:

Build trust through genuine representation of SA contexts, using local models in recognisable settings and partnering with credible community influencers who have established authentic relationships with target demographics. Visual content quality significantly influences trust formation on Instagram.

Establish verified review systems:

Combat review scepticism by implementing robust verification mechanisms that highlight feedback from confirmed purchasers, particularly those from similar demographic profiles and geographic regions. Quality reviews from verified sources prove more influential than volume alone.

Provide comprehensive privacy policies:

Develop clear, accessible communications about data collection and usage that explain consumer benefits while addressing legitimate privacy concerns. Transparent privacy management builds rather than erodes consumer confidence.

Create community-driven support systems:

Foster peer-to-peer assistance through moderated community spaces where experienced customers can provide guidance to potential buyers, building trust through authentic social proof. Social support mechanisms significantly enhance trust formation in online environments.

Retailers that successfully implement comprehensive Instagram commerce strategies and invest in sophisticated trust-building mechanisms are positioned to capture significant market share in the growing SA athleisure sector. By conducting thorough trust assessments and developing culturally relevant approaches to risk management, marketers can effectively leverage Instagram's commercial capabilities to increase engagement, build lasting loyalty, and create sustainable revenue growth among Generation Y male consumers.

The Instagram economy presents both unprecedented opportunities and complex challenges for SA athleisure retailers. Success requires moving beyond traditional marketing approaches to embrace trust-centric strategies that acknowledge and address the legitimate concerns of sophisticated digital consumers while delivering the authentic, engaging experiences they increasingly demand.

References: